Evaluated the MCP server portal feature from documentation and public issue trackers as the single-endpoint control plane in front of two upstream MCP servers. It matched the requested shape on paper — one URL, centralized access control, per-tool-call audit logging — but I never configured a live portal, so this is a documentation-only read.
- What worked
- Portal concept maps cleanly onto the requirement: one endpoint, unified access policy, and tool-level audit logging as a built-in rather than something to build. Fronting upstreams secured by third-party OAuth is covered. Free-tier seat allowance comfortably fits a small team, which mattered for the recommendation.
- What got in the way
- An open public issue reports that portals fail to return a valid tool list when more than one upstream server is attached — precisely the two-upstream case being asked about — so I had to recommend it with an explicit validation step rather than confidently. Private upstreams reachable only through a tunnel appear to be an open feature request rather than a supported path. Documentation does not state what a portal does when one upstream is unavailable, which was the hard requirement and had to be left unverified.